W
What does it take to keep growing when you’re already one of the best in the game?
In this episode of When the Cleats Come Off, Ashley welcomes back Erin Coffel, the reigning AUSL Hitter of the Year, for a live, mid-season conversation that pulls back the curtain on elite development at the professional level. From training with Team USA to refining her approach during the offseason, Erin shares how continuous growth — not comfort — has fueled her success.
This episode is a powerful reminder that confidence doesn’t eliminate nerves, and mastery doesn’t mean you stop evolving.
Growth Doesn’t Stop at the Top
Erin reflects on her journey from her first professional season — when she admits she didn’t always feel like herself — to now leading the AUSL in nearly every major offensive category. She shares how adjustments in preparation, mindset, and self-trust helped her bridge the gap between potential and performance.
Rather than chasing perfection, Erin emphasizes patience, curiosity, and the willingness to stay open to learning — even after earning top honors.
Â
Training With the Best in the World
One of the standout moments of the episode is Erin’s insight into training camp with United States Women's National Softball Team, led by head coach Patty Gasso.
She discusses the intensity, attention to detail, and accountability that define the environment — and how those standards elevate everyone involved. Erin also talks about working with Florida Gators Softball during the offseason and how that experience continues to sharpen her game.
Â
Confidence, Butterflies, and Competing Free
Even at the professional level, nerves don’t disappear — and Erin is refreshingly honest about that reality.
She opens up about still getting butterflies before competing and why she now sees them as a sign of care, not weakness. Learning to compete with nerves instead of against them has allowed her to stay present, aggressive, and confident in big moments.
This conversation reinforces that elite performance isn’t about eliminating emotion — it’s about managing it.
Â
What You’ll Learn in This Episode
-
Why growth never stops — even at the top
How elite athletes continue evolving. -
Lessons from Team USA training camp
Standards, preparation, and accountability at the highest level. -
How Erin found herself as a pro
Adjustments that led to confidence and consistency. -
Why nerves don’t mean you’re not ready
Reframing butterflies as part of competing. -
What it really means to get better
Staying curious, disciplined, and open to change.
About
Erin Coffel
Erin Coffel is a professional softball standout and one of the most productive hitters in the AUSL. Known for her power, consistency, and work ethic, she continues to set the standard for what it looks like to pursue excellence while staying grounded in the process.
Her willingness to share both her growth and her challenges makes her a powerful voice for athletes navigating transitions at the highest level.
Connect with Erin:
-
Instagram: @erin.coffel
