The college recruiting process can feel overwhelming for many athletes and families. With so many moving parts—camps, communication with coaches, highlight videos, and social media—it’s easy to feel unsure about where to start or how to stand out.
In this episode of When the Cleats Come Off, Ashley sits down with returning guest Tisha Mahon to break down how athletes can take ownership of their recruiting journey. Tisha shares practical advice on how players can position themselves for opportunities, build confidence during the recruiting process, and present themselves in a way that catches the attention of college coaches.
For athletes hoping to play at the next level, this conversation provides a roadmap for approaching recruiting with clarity and confidence.
Taking Ownership of the Recruiting Process
One of the biggest mistakes athletes make is assuming that recruiting will simply happen for them.
Tisha explains why athletes must take an active role in their recruiting journey—from reaching out to coaches to attending camps and showcasing their skills. When athletes learn how to advocate for themselves and communicate effectively, they dramatically increase their chances of being noticed.
Recruiting success often comes from preparation, persistence, and confidence.
Standing Out to College Coaches
With so many athletes competing for limited roster spots, standing out requires more than just strong performance.
Tisha shares the small but important details coaches notice when evaluating players, including effort, coachability, body language, and how athletes handle adversity. These qualities often give coaches a better sense of how a player will fit into their program and team culture.
Athletes who focus on these elements can make a lasting impression.
Building Confidence During Recruiting
Recruiting can sometimes feel intimidating, especially when athletes are competing in front of college coaches.
Tisha discusses how athletes can approach camps and recruiting events with confidence by focusing on preparation and mindset. Trusting the work they’ve put in allows athletes to compete freely and show coaches what they’re truly capable of.
Confidence often becomes the difference between blending in and standing out.
What You’ll Learn in This Episode
-
How athletes can take control of their recruiting journey
-
What college coaches notice most when evaluating players
-
How to prepare for camps and recruiting opportunities
-
Why confidence plays a major role in standing out
-
Practical ways athletes can position themselves for college opportunities
About
Tisha Mahon
Tisha Mahon is a softball recruiting expert and coach who helps athletes and families navigate the college recruiting process with clarity and confidence. A graduate of University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Tisha brings both her playing background and more than a decade of coaching experience to the athletes she works with.
Throughout her coaching career, she has specialized in hitting, slapping, and outfield development, while also mentoring athletes through the recruiting journey. Her coaching philosophy centers on listening, collaboration, and helping athletes grow into their best selves both on and off the field.
Today, Tisha works closely with players across the country, helping them build confidence, develop their personal brand, and position themselves for opportunities at the collegiate level.
Connect with Tisha:Â
Instagram: @empoweredisshe
Â
